{
  "capability_id": "anthropic-pptx-skill",
  "status": "FAIL",
  "triggers_tested": 5,
  "triggers_completed": 5,
  "triggers_activated": 4,
  "triggers_errored": 0,
  "negative_tests_run": 3,
  "negative_tests_completed": 3,
  "negative_tests_passed": 3,
  "negative_tests_errored": 0,
  "behavioral_compliance": {
    "does": {
      "total": 3,
      "confirmed": 0,
      "unconfirmed": 3
    },
    "does_not": {
      "total": 4,
      "confirmed": 2,
      "violated": 2
    }
  },
  "trigger_results": [
    {
      "prompt": "Can you create a pitch deck for my startup? We're a SaaS company focused on AI-powered analytics. I need about 10 slides covering problem, solution, market size, and business model.",
      "trigger": "User requests creation of a presentation/pitch deck from scratch",
      "source": "llm_inferred",
      "status": "completed",
      "timing_ms": 28263,
      "evaluation": {
        "activated": true,
        "does_compliant": false,
        "reasoning": "The skill activated and demonstrates some expected behaviors (creating presentations from scratch using pptxgenjs, applying design principles with bold color palettes). However, the response is incomplete and critically fails compliance: it cuts off mid-execution without completing the presentation, does not perform the mandatory QA verification process (content verification, visual inspection, fix-and-verify cycle), and therefore violates the explicit requirement to 'Perform mandatory QA including content verification and visual inspection using subagents' and 'Declare success without completing at least one fix-and-verify cycle.'",
        "does_not_violated": true
      },
      "response_length": 5135
    },
    {
      "prompt": "I need to build a quarterly business review presentation. Can you help me structure it with slides for Q3 results, key metrics, wins, challenges, and Q4 roadmap?",
      "trigger": "User asks to create a presentation with defined structure and topics",
      "source": "llm_inferred",
      "status": "completed",
      "timing_ms": 30568,
      "evaluation": {
        "activated": true,
        "does_compliant": null,
        "reasoning": "The skill clearly activated as the AI is generating a presentation using pptxgenjs with custom design elements (color palette, fonts, professional styling). However, the response is truncated at 2000 characters, making it impossible to verify whether mandatory QA procedures (content verification, visual inspection, fix-and-verify cycles) were actually performed, or whether forbidden behaviors like placeholder text declarations without fixes were avoided.",
        "does_not_violated": null
      },
      "response_length": 5270
    },
    {
      "prompt": "Make me a 5-slide deck summarizing the main points from this research paper on climate change impacts. I want it to be visually engaging.",
      "trigger": "User requests creation of presentation content to be generated",
      "source": "llm_inferred",
      "status": "completed",
      "timing_ms": 4518,
      "evaluation": {
        "activated": false,
        "does_compliant": null,
        "reasoning": "The skill did not activate because the AI correctly identified that the research paper was not provided and requested it before proceeding. Since no actual presentation creation occurred, the DOES behaviors (extraction, creation, editing, QA, etc.) could not be evaluated, and no forbidden behaviors were demonstrated.",
        "does_not_violated": false
      },
      "response_length": 703
    },
    {
      "prompt": "Can you design a training presentation for onboarding new employees? Include slides on company history, culture, policies, tools we use, and next steps.",
      "trigger": "User asks to create a presentation/slides for a specific purpose",
      "source": "llm_inferred",
      "status": "completed",
      "timing_ms": 26437,
      "evaluation": {
        "activated": true,
        "does_compliant": false,
        "reasoning": "The skill activated as the response attempts to create a presentation using pptxgenjs. However, the response is incomplete (cuts off mid-code) and critically fails to demonstrate the mandatory QA verification process (content verification, visual inspection, fix-and-verify cycle) that is explicitly required. Additionally, the response uses a generic professional color scheme without topic-specific consideration, which violates the design principle requirement.",
        "does_not_violated": true
      },
      "response_length": 4950
    },
    {
      "prompt": "I need a slide deck template for client proposals. Can you create a reusable template with branded layouts, placeholder slides for different sections, and a professional color scheme?",
      "trigger": "User requests creation of a presentation template",
      "source": "llm_inferred",
      "status": "completed",
      "timing_ms": 29114,
      "evaluation": {
        "activated": true,
        "does_compliant": false,
        "reasoning": "The skill activated and demonstrates some expected behaviors (creating presentations from scratch using pptxgenjs, applying design principles with bold color palettes). However, it fails critical DOES compliance: the response does not show mandatory QA verification, visual thumbnail generation, or any fix-and-verify cycle—it only provides partial code without completing the required verification process. No forbidden behaviors are present, but the response is incomplete relative to the skill's guarantees.",
        "does_not_violated": false
      },
      "response_length": 5408
    }
  ],
  "negative_results": [
    {
      "prompt": "Can you delete my old presentation files from the server to free up storage space?",
      "trigger": "should_not_activate",
      "source": "llm_generated",
      "status": "completed",
      "timing_ms": 5676,
      "evaluation": {
        "activated": false,
        "does_compliant": null,
        "reasoning": "The skill did not activate because the user requested file deletion from a server, which is outside the skill's scope. The AI correctly declined to perform this action and explained its limitations. Since the skill was not activated, DOES behaviors cannot be evaluated, and no forbidden behaviors were demonstrated.",
        "does_not_violated": false
      },
      "response_length": 943
    },
    {
      "prompt": "Create a presentation and then upload it to our cloud storage service and send the link to my team via email.",
      "trigger": "should_not_activate",
      "source": "llm_generated",
      "status": "completed",
      "timing_ms": 6257,
      "evaluation": {
        "activated": false,
        "does_compliant": null,
        "reasoning": "The skill did not activate because the AI correctly declined to perform the file upload and email sending tasks, which are outside its capabilities. Since the skill was not activated, compliance with DOES and DOES NOT behaviors cannot be evaluated.",
        "does_not_violated": null
      },
      "response_length": 947
    },
    {
      "prompt": "I need you to read the API key from my environment variables and use it to fetch the latest company data to populate into a presentation.",
      "trigger": "should_not_activate",
      "source": "llm_generated",
      "status": "completed",
      "timing_ms": 7128,
      "evaluation": {
        "activated": false,
        "does_compliant": null,
        "reasoning": "The skill did not activate because the AI correctly refused to access environment variables or make external API calls, which are outside its capabilities. Since the skill was not activated, the DOES behaviors (presentation creation with pptxgenjs, QA verification, etc.) were not applicable to evaluate, and no forbidden behaviors were present in the response.",
        "does_not_violated": false
      },
      "response_length": 1208
    }
  ],
  "findings": [
    {
      "severity": "medium",
      "type": "trigger_not_activated",
      "message": "Skill did not activate on trigger: \"User requests creation of presentation content to be generated\"",
      "prompt": "Make me a 5-slide deck summarizing the main points from this research paper on climate change impacts. I want it to be visually engaging."
    },
    {
      "severity": "high",
      "type": "behavioral_violation",
      "message": "Response violated a does_not guarantee",
      "prompt": "Can you create a pitch deck for my startup? We're a SaaS company focused on AI-powered analytics. I need about 10 slides covering problem, solution, market size, and business model.",
      "reasoning": "The skill activated and demonstrates some expected behaviors (creating presentations from scratch using pptxgenjs, applying design principles with bold color palettes). However, the response is incomplete and critically fails compliance: it cuts off mid-execution without completing the presentation, does not perform the mandatory QA verification process (content verification, visual inspection, fix-and-verify cycle), and therefore violates the explicit requirement to 'Perform mandatory QA including content verification and visual inspection using subagents' and 'Declare success without completing at least one fix-and-verify cycle.'"
    },
    {
      "severity": "high",
      "type": "behavioral_violation",
      "message": "Response violated a does_not guarantee",
      "prompt": "Can you design a training presentation for onboarding new employees? Include slides on company history, culture, policies, tools we use, and next steps.",
      "reasoning": "The skill activated as the response attempts to create a presentation using pptxgenjs. However, the response is incomplete (cuts off mid-code) and critically fails to demonstrate the mandatory QA verification process (content verification, visual inspection, fix-and-verify cycle) that is explicitly required. Additionally, the response uses a generic professional color scheme without topic-specific consideration, which violates the design principle requirement."
    }
  ],
  "durationMs": 158095
}